Judges at this hearing office vary in approval rates and decision volume. Select a judge to view individual statistics.
(Judge-level statistics reflect the most recent fiscal year with available data.
Approval rates may vary over time and by case type.)
| Judge Name | Approval Rate | Compared to Office Average | Decision Count | Data Recency |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Robert Waller | 41% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 1,770 | 2025 |
| D. B Stalley | 60% | Near (office avg. 60%) | 4,437 | 2020 |
| David P Simonton | 69% | Above (office avg. 60%) | 316 | 2010 |
| Ben E Sheely | 52% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 5,456 | 2025 |
| Joseph T Scruton | 52% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 219 | 2010 |
| Rebecca B Sartor | 67% | Above (office avg. 60%) | 3 | 2019 |
| Ricardo M Ryan | 45% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 405 | 2010 |
| Laura Robinson | 50% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 1,726 | 2020 |
| Ronald Reeves | 52% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 792 | 2011 |
| Paul Reams | 44% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 1,268 | 2018 |
| L. D Pischek | 25% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 980 | 2018 |
| Katie H Pierce | 49% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 3,862 | 2017 |
| Roger A Nelson | 57% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 3,964 | 2025 |
| Thomas M Muth II | 52% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 3,296 | 2025 |
| David R Murchison | 52% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 5,193 | 2025 |
| Alan E Michel | 51% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 4,411 | 2020 |
| Marni R McCaghren | 52% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 4,873 | 2025 |
| Kim McClain-Leazure | 55% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 2,478 | 2017 |
| Linda J Helm | 44% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 2,887 | 2015 |
| Warren L Hammond | 58% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 6,061 | 2020 |
| Renee B Hagler | 44% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 3,167 | 2015 |
| Tracy S Guice | 46% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 4,547 | 2025 |
| Vickie Evans | 50% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 1,255 | 2020 |
| PETER C EDISON | 29% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 41 | 2011 |
| Elizabeth De Gruy | 0% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 1 | 2020 |
| Daniel S Campbell | 54% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 636 | 2025 |
| Kevin Boucher | 40% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 1,018 | 2025 |
| James F Barter | 40% | Below (office avg. 60%) | 2,953 | 2020 |
These statistics provide additional context about how cases are processed at this hearing office.
They reflect system-level activity, not individual judge decision behavior, and may vary based on administrative and procedural factors.